Fabian Zander (opens in new tab), Senior Research Fellow in Aerospace Engineering, University of Southern Queensland
In the past week alone, we’ve seen two separate incidents of space debris hurtling back to Earth in unexpected places.
On Saturday there was the uncontrolled re-entry of a Chinese Long March 5B rocket over Malaysia. Yesterday, news outlets reported on some spacecraft parts that turned up in regional New South Wales – now confirmed (opens in new tab) to be from a SpaceX Crew-1 mission.
As the space industry grows, it’s safe to say such incidents will only become more frequent – and they could pose a risk. But how much of a risk, exactly?
Space debris refers to the leftover components of a space system that are no longer required. It might be a satellite that has reached the end of its life (such as the International Space Station), or parts of a rocket system that have fulfilled their purpose and are discarded.
To date, China has launched three Long March 5B rockets, and each has been deliberately left in an uncontrolled orbit. This means there was no way of knowing where they would land.
As for the SpaceX debris found in the Snowy Mountains, SpaceX de-orbits its rocket parts in a controlled fashion, and designs other components to burn up upon re-entry into Earth’s atmosphere. But as you can see from the latest news, these things don’t always go to plan.
So how dangerous is space debris, really?
Well, as far as we know only one person has ever been hit by it. Lottie Williams, a resident of Tulsa, Oklahoma, was (opens in new tab) struck by a piece in 1997. It was about the size of her hand and thought to have come from a Delta II rocket. She picked it up, took it home and reported it to authorities the next day.
However, with more and more objects going into space, and coming back down, the chances of someone or something being struck are increasing. This is especially true of large, uncontrolled objects such as the Long March 5B.
Of the three times this model of rocket has been launched:
- the first re-entered on May 11, 2020, with components landing on an African village (opens in new tab);
- the second re-entered on May 9, 2021, near the Maldives;
- the third re-entered on Saturday over Indonesia and Malaysia, with debris landing around these islands.
So should I be worried?
There are many different estimates of the chances of space debris hitting someone, but most are in the one-in-10,000 (opens in new tab) range. This is the chance of any person being hit, anywhere in the world. However, the chances of a particular person being hit (such as you or me) is in the order of one in a trillion (opens in new tab).
There are several factors behind these estimates, but let’s just focus on one key one for now. The image below shows the orbital path the recent Long March 5B-Y3 rocket followed for its final 24 hours (different objects take different orbital paths), as well as its re-entry location marked in red.
As you can see, the rocket orbits above land for a substantial amount of time.
Specifically, in these orbits the vehicle spends about 20% of its time over land. A broad estimate tells us 20% of land is inhabited, which means there is a 4% chance of the Long March 5B re-entry occurring over an inhabited area.
This may seem pretty high. But when you consider how much “inhabited land” is actually covered by people, the likelihood of injury or death becomes significantly less.
The chance of damage to property, on the other hand, is higher. It could be as high as 1% for any given re-entry of the Long March 5B.
Also, the overall risk posed by space debris will increase with the sheer number of objects being launched and re-entering the atmosphere. Current plans of companies and space agencies around the world involve many, many more launches.
China’s Tiangong Space Station is due to (opens in new tab) be finished by the end of the year. And South Korea recently became (opens in new tab) the seventh country to launch a satellite payload heavier than one tonne – with plans to expand (opens in new tab) its space sector (along with (opens in new tab) Japan, Russia, India and United Arab Emirates).
It’s highly likely the chances of being hit are only going to go up (but will hopefully remain very small).
How can we be prepared?
Two questions come to mind:
Let’s start with predictions. It can be extremely challenging to predict where an object in an uncontrolled orbit will re-enter Earth’s atmosphere. The general rule of thumb says uncertainty of the estimated re-entry time will be between 10% and 20% of the remaining orbital time.
This means an object with a predicted re-entry time in ten hours will have an uncertainty margin of about one hour. So if an object is orbiting Earth every 60-90 minutes, it could enter pretty much anywhere.
Improving on this uncertainty margin is a big challenge and will require significant amounts of research. Even then, it’s unlikely we’ll be able to predict an object’s re-entry location more accurately than within a 1,000km range.
Latest update on the Chinese rocket booster from @AerospaceCorpThe current tracking has it crashing in about 6 hours, at 5:15 pm UT 30 July / 31 July at 3:15 am AEST / 10:15am 30 July US Pacific Time. pic.twitter.com/FTSgiWKg6FJuly 30, 2022
Ways to reduce risk
Reducing risk is a challenge, but there are a couple of options.
First, all objects launched into an Earth orbit should have a plan for safe de-orbiting into an unpopulated area. This is usually the SPOUA (South Pacific Ocean Uninhabited Area) – also known as the “spacecraft cemetery.”
There’s also the option to carefully design components so they completely disintegrate upon re-entry. If everything burns up when it hits the upper atmosphere, there will no longer be a significant risk.
There are already some guidelines requiring space debris risk minimization, such as the United Nations guidelines (opens in new tab) for the Long-term Sustainability of Outer Space Activities – but the mechanisms for these aren’t specified.
Moreover, how do these guidelines apply internationally, and who can enforce them? Such questions remain unanswered.
In summary, should you be concerned about being hit by space debris? For now, no. Is further research on space debris important for the future? Absolutely.
Follow all of the Expert Voices issues and debates — and become part of the discussion — on Facebook and Twitter. The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
Fields of Research (FoR):
Aerospace Engineering not elsewhere classified ( 400199 )
Hypersonic Propulsion And Hypersonic Aerothermodynamics ( 400106 )
Aerospace Engineering ( 400100 )
Member of American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics
USQ Research affiliations:
Institute for Advanced Engineering and Space Sciences (IAESS)